Not your keys, not your coins: Locke, Epictetus and the $6.3 billion question
This post analyzes the $6.3B Binance hack via John Locke (property via labor) and Epictetus (Stoic control). It argues that leaving crypto on an exchange means holding a promise, not the asset. True ownership requires self-custody of private keys, blending Locke's property rights with Epictetus's advice to prepare for the worst and accept only what is truly in your control.
You bought the coins.
You checked your balance this morning.
The numbers add up.
You feel safe and content.
Epictetus would ask: is it yours?
On October 29, 2026, at approximately 20 05 UTC, money started leaving Binance, the largest cryptocurrency exchange in the world. Around $6.3 billion was moved out of its wallets across 10 blockchains, and the bulk of it occurred in around 20 minutes. The FBI has since attributed the attack to TraderTraitor, a North Korean state-sponsored hacking unit, which was also behind the $1.5 billion Bybit heist in February 2025. It has, since then, been named the greatest cryptocurrency hack in history.
It was not a shortcoming of Bitcoin, nor was it a broken smart contract. According to the co-CEO of Binance, Richard Teng, the first investigation trail uncovered a far more mundane cause: a DevOps engineer’s compromised laptop provided the attacker with access to a service container. The subsequent investigation uncovered a myriad of additional breach points.
The cryptography was resilient, while everything else surrounding is, was not.
In 1689, John Locke published his Second Treatise of Government and cunningly asked a rather straightforward question; how does anything become yours?
His answer was; labour. He described that every man “has property in his own person”. When you take something from nature, and mix your labour with it, for example picking a fruit, or ploughing a field, you merge with it something that belongs to you. It henceforth becomes your property. It is a gift from no one, but rather, an indisputable natural right. Locke consequently believed that protecting this right was one of the main reasons why governments should even exist.
Crypto is possibly the most Lockean invention of the modern era. It stands on the idea that it constitutes property that cannot be seized by any ruler, and cannot be frozen by any bank; its security not locked behind promises, but ensured by complex mathematics. Retain the private key, and the coins are yours in the purest definition Locke could have envisaged.
There is, however, one main issue: most people do not possess the key.
When you leave your coins on an exchange, you do not actually own the coins. The exchange retains the keys. What you somewhat own, is a claim that when you require it, you will be handed over the number displayed on your screen.
On a random, ordinary day, there is not much of a difference between the coin and the promise. However, the difference is very apparent when $6.3 billion vanishes in 20 minutes.
Notwithstanding, Binance managed to uphold its promise:
It cast aside $6.34 billion in company funds and pledged to absorb the losses itself, instead of passing them onto the users/
It replenished approximately 95% of the stolen assets.
Withdrawals resumed in phases on November 1st.
But a promise kept is still a promise. A US bankruptcy judge ruled in 2023 that the crypto in Celcius’ customers’ interest-bearing accounts belonged not to them, but to the company. People who believed they owned coins learnt that they were merely creditors waiting in line.
16 centuries before Locke, a man who owned nothing, not even himself, had a very different answer.
Epictetus was a slave born in the first century AD, and was owned by Epaphroditus, a secretary to the emperor Nero. He was later freed and became a philosopher; and was subsequently exiled from Rome by the emperor Domitian. A man, who at some point in life, owned not even his own body, saw no point in the idea that any external entity truly belonged to anyone.
The Enchridion, the handbook of his teachings, starts with the line summing up his entire philosophy: “Some things are in our power, and others are not.” Our actions, decisions and judgements are ours; while our bodies, our property and our reputation are not, and can be taken from us at any moment by forces we have no control over. He furthermore builds on this idea with the notion that everything external is, in fact, on loan. “Never say anything, I have lost it; but, I have restored it.”
Locke would object, and he would have every right to. Property rights matter, and theft is theft, and after all, those holding others’ assets owe them protection. Nonetheless, the two philosophers do not necessarily answer the same question here. Locke tells you what you are entitled to, while Epictetus informs you of what you can rely on.
As you had no control over TraderTraitor targeting Binance, or the engineer’s compromised endpoint, or the $6.34 billion the exchange had to spare, all of it was never yours to begin with. It was all external, as Epictetus would say.
The only thing that was in your control was one single decision, that you made long before October 29th: where your property resided, and how much of it.
Stoicism is not resignation, but instead, acceptance. Seneca, another stoic, in premeditatio malorum explained that one should rehearse misfortune in advance so that it never comes as a surprise. For example, you could eat exclusively plain bread for a week in case there is a shortage of food someday. In the software development world, we run countless tests to prepare for the worst. Likewise, Binance partly made it out precisely because of this. It created its SAFU fund in 2018. 8 years back, someone decided to save for a rainy day.
In crypto, stoicism is not passivity or blind acceptance; it is preparation. You should be aware of what you hold; keys or a claim. If the keys are held by someone else, you merely own a promise. You should be acquainted with the custody terms, and you should never keep more on a single platform, than you can afford to lose.
Locke gave us the language of ownership, while Epictetus ingrained in us the discipline to learn where it ends.
More often than not, losses begin with one trivial assumption; the number on the screen is mine as it has always been there. Therefore, find the balance in your portfolio that you assume is yours. That is not your property. It is a promise. And you should decide, today, how much you are willing to stake on it.